| 2024 | ^Troy Vannucci | Little Mill CC | 64-68=132 | Concord CC |
| Format changed to 54 holes of stroke play |
| 2023 | *Logan Paczewski | Huntsville GC | 66-72=138 | Llanerch CC |
| Playoff (four-hole aggregate): Paczewski (14), Matthew Mattare (15) & Austin Barbin (16)
|
| 2022 | *Drue Nicholas | Galloway National GC | 63-70=133 | St. Davids GC |
| Playoff: Nicholas wins with a par vs. bogey on fifth extra hole; (Four-hole aggregate): Nicholas (15) & Michael R. Brown, Jr. (15) |
| 2021 | Peter Bradbeer | Merion GC | 131 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| 2020 | *#Zach Barbin | Loch Nairn GC | 67 | The 1912 Club |
| Playoff (four-hole aggregate): Barbin (15), Jeff Osberg (16), & Gregor Orlando (17) |
| 2019 | #Jeff Osberg | Pine Valley GC | 67 | Applebrook GC |
| 2018 | Michael R. Brown, Jr. | Lu Lu CC | 138 | Gulph Mills GC |
| 2017 | Peter Bradbeer | Merion GC | 140 | Wilmington CC (South) |
| 2016 | *Jeff Osberg | Huntingdon Valley CC | 137 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| | Playoff (four-hole aggregate): Osberg (16) & David Hicks (18) |
| 2015 | Christopher Crawford | Spring Mill CC | 137 | Chester Valley GC |
| 2014 | Cole Berman | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 140 | Tavistock CC |
| 2013 | Brandon Matthews | Glenmaura National GC | 134 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 2012 | #Brandon Matthews | Fox Hill CC | 65 | Philadelphia CC |
| | Second round cancelled due to unplayable course conditions |
| 2011 | Andrew Mason | Huntingdon Valley CC | 140 | White Manor CC |
| 2010 | Jeff Osberg | Llanerch CC | 136 | RiverCrest GC & Preserve |
| 2009 | James Kania, Jr. | Overbrook GC | 140 | Llanerch CC |
| 2008 | Glenn Smeraglio | Yardley CC | 136 | St. Davids GC/Waynesborough CC |
| 2007 | Michael McDermott | Merion GC | 136 | Berkleigh CC/Moselem Springs GC |
| 2006 | Stephen Arnold | Yardley CC | 139 | Philmont CC (North/South) |
| 2005 | *Tug Maude | Merion GC | 138 | Concord CC/Radley Run CC |
| | Playoff: Maude (71) & Conrad Von Borsig (74) | |
| 2004 | Michael A. Tash | Tavistock CC | 143 | Laurel Creek CC/Tavistock CC |
| 2003 | Chris Gallagher | Penn Oaks GC | 137 | Bellewood GC/Spring Ford CC |
| 2002 | Michael A. Tash | Tavistock CC | 145 | Applebrook GC/Aronimink GC |
| 2001 | Jamie Slonis | Little Mill CC | 144 | Fieldstone GC/Wilmington CC (South) |
| 2000 | *Greg O’Connor | Huntingdon Valley CC | 144 | Commonwealth National GC/Huntingdon Valley CC |
| | Playoff: %O’Connor (75), Christian Bartolacci (75) & Mike Gregor (76) |
| | % — O’Connor parred first hole in a sudden-death playoff with Bartolacci |
| 1999 | Chris Lange | Overbrook GC | 149 | Old York Road CC/Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1998 | Glenn Smeraglio | Yardley CC | 144 | Lu Lu CC/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| | Playoff: Smeraglio (73) & Chris Sekella (75) | |
| 1997 | Michael A. Tash | Woodbury CC | 148 | Laurel Creek CC/Riverton CC |
| 1996 | David K. Brookreson | Huntingdon Valley CC | 144 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Sandy Run CC |
| 1995 | James Kania, Sr. | Overbrook GC | 141 | Overbrook GC/Philadelphia CC |
| 1994 | #Chris Lange | Overbrook GC | 71 | North Hills CC |
| | Lu Lu CC unplayable due to severe winter weather |
| 1993 | George E. Marucci, Jr. | Pine Valley GC | 146 | Riverton CC/Tavistock CC |
| 1992 | Brad McFadden | Overbrook GC | 143 | Aronimink GC/Overbrook GC |
| 1991 | *David K. Brookreson | Huntingdon Valley CC | 146 | Gulph Mills GC/Waynesborough CC |
| | Playoff: Brookreson (73), P. Chet Walsh (77) & Mike Gregor (80) |
| 1990 | Blaise Giroso | Brandywine CC | 143 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| 1989 | #*Chris Lange | Overbrook GC | 75 | Chester Valley GC |
| | Playoff: Lange (73), P. Chet Walsh (74), Art Kania (75) & Frank Corrado (78) |
| 1988 | Chris Terebesi | Chester Valley GC | 144 | Lu Lu CC |
| 1987 | *John Sweeney | Saucon Valley CC | 144 | Riverton CC |
| 1986 | R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 138 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wisahickon) |
| 1985 | R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 142 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1984 | Herman J. Fry | Reading CC | 147 | Woodcrest CC |
| 1983 | #*Blaise Giroso | Brandywine CC | 72 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| | Playoff: Giroso (69), Mike Rose (73), Mike Heller (76), David K. Brookreson (78), Joseph Data (82) & George E. Marucci, Jr. (DNS) |
| 1982 | Paul Erhardt, III | Wilmington CC | 141 | Green Valley CC |
| 1981 | Paul Erhardt, III | Chester Valley GC | 137 | The Springhaven Club |
| 1980 | R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 143 | Llanerch CC/Merion GC (East) |
| 1979 | Gary Deetscreek | Old York Road CC | 146 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Philmont CC (North) |
| 1978 | *Charles Bolling, Jr. | Gulph Mills GC | 145 | Meadowlands CC/Old York Road CC |
| | Playoff: Bolling (73) & Paul Erhardt, III (74) | |
| 1977 | James Robertson | Llanerch CC | 147 | Gulph Mills GC/Philadelphia CC |
| 1976 | Duke Delcher | Sandy Run CC | 143 | The Springhaven Club |
| 1975 | Donald DeAngelis | Plymouth CC | 146 | Gulph Mills GC |
| 1974 | Robert B. Kotz | Trenton CC | 146 | Trenton CC |
| 1973 | *George E. Marucci, Jr. | Llanerch CC | 147 | St. Davids GC |
| | Playoff: Marucci, Jr. (74) & O. Gordon Brewer, Jr. (79) |
| 1972 | R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 144 | Whitford CC |
| 1971 | Robert S. Martino | Bala GC | 145 | Green Valley CC |
| 1970 | R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 141 | Merion GC (East/West) |
| 1969 | *William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 150 | Aronimink GC/Waynesborough CC |
| | Playoff: Hyndman, III (73) & Thomas Apple (79) |
| 1968 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 142 | Meadowlands CC/Sandy Run CC |
| 1967 | William H. Care, Jr. | Atlantic City CC | 143 | Wilmington CC (North/South) |
| 1966 | *James King | Cedarbrook CC | 146 | Old York Road CC/Squires GC |
| Playoff: King (74) & William H. Care, Jr. (79) | |
| 1965 | *William H. Care, Jr. | Atlantic City CC | 145 | North Hills CC/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| | Playoff: Care (75) & William Robinson, Jr. (76) | |
| 1964 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 143 | Riverton CC/Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| 1963 | *William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 146 | Philadelphia CC/Plymouth CC |
| | Playoff: Hyndman, III (75) & John H. Guenther, Jr. (77) |
| 1962 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 141 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Philmont CC (North) |
| 1961 | Howard Everitt | Atlantic City CC | 151 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Sunnybrook GC |
| 1960 | John H. Guenther, Jr. | Berkshire CC | 142 | Aronimink GC/The Springhaven Club |
| 1959 | Wayne Bancroft | Tavistock CC | 147 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1958 | Richard A. Stephens | Aronimink GC | 145 | Aronimink GC/The Springhaven Club |
| 1957 | John Dyniewski | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 142 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Philmont CC North) |
| 1956 | Howard Everitt | Atlantic City CC | 143 | Aronimink GC/Merion GC (East) |
| 1955 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 141 | North Hills CC/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1954 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 145 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1953 | John Dyniewski | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 145 | Aronimink GC/St. Davids GC |
| 1952 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 149 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Philmont CC (North) |
| 1951 | W.B. McCullough, Jr. | Huntingdon Valley CC | 147 | North Hills CC/Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1950 | George H. Rowbotham | Aronimink GC | 142 | Aronimink GC/St. Davids GC |
| 1949 | W.B. McCullough, Jr. | Huntingdon Valley CC | 144 | Merion GC (East)/Philadelphia CC |
| 1948 | James B. McHale, Jr. | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 146 | Manufacturers’ G&CC/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1947 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 144 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1946 | William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 147 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1945 | No contest — World War II |
| 1944 | No contest — World War II |
| 1943 | No contest — World War II |
| 1942 | W.B. McCullough, Jr. | Huntingdon Valley CC | 152 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1941 | J. Wood Platt | The Springhaven Club | 140 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1940 | Howard Everitt | Manufacturers’ G&CC | 147 | Huntingdon Valley CC/Old York Road CC |
| 1939 | W.B. McCullough, Jr. | Huntingdon Valley CC | 146 | Philmont CC (North/South) |
| 1938 | J. Wood Platt | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 145 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon)/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1937 | Andrew H. Kaye | Old York Road CC | 146 | Philmont CC (North/South) |
| 1936 | Maxwell R. Marston | Merion Cricket Club | 149 | Merion Cricket Club |
| 1935 | Harold S. Cross, Jr. | Huntingdon Valley CC | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club/Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1934 | Chris Brinke | Aronimink GC | 144 | Aronimink GC/St. Davids GC |
| 1933 | William E. Kirsh | Rolling Green GC | 154 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1932 | John J. Jennings | Melrose CC | 145 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1931 | Harold Cuthbert | Ashbourne CC | 151 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1930 | Charles A. Reckner | Cedarbrook CC | 150 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1929 | J. G. Boardman | Ashbourne CC | 150 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1928 | J. Wood Platt | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 147 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1927 | *D.C. Corkran | Huntingdon Valley CC | 153 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| | Playoff: Corkran (76) & Theodore Johnston (80) | |
| 1926 | J. Wood Platt | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 148 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1925 | E.B. Leisenring | Huntingdon Valley CC | 156 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1924 | Maxwell R. Marston | Merion Cricket Club | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1923 | Maxwell R. Marston | Merion Cricket Club | 151 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 1922 | George W. Hoffner | Bala GC | 151 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1921 | *Robert Hoffner | Philmont CC | 152 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| | Playoff: Hoffner, Maxwell R. Marston & Norman H. Maxwell |
| 1920 | Maxwell R. Marston | Merion Cricket Club | 148 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1919 | *Norman H. Maxwell | Overbrook GC | 155 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| | Playoff: Maxwell & Harold A. Sands | | |
| 1918 | Norman H. Maxwell | Aronimink GC | 155 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1917 | Fred W. Knight | Aronimink GC | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1916 | E.C. Clarey | Merion Cricket Club | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1915 | Harold A. Sands | Merion Cricket Club | 159 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1914 | Simon Carr | Huntingdon Valley CC | 154 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1913 | Cecil B. Calvert | Bala CC | 161 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1912 | George A. Crump | Philadelphia CC | 158 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1911 | Robert C. James | The Springhaven Club | 157 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 1910 | H.R. Worthington | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1909 | *Harold B. McFarland | Huntingdon Valley CC | 157 | The Springhaven Club |
| | Playoff: McFarland & C.R. Stull | | |
| 1908 | William P. Smith | Huntingdon Valley CC | 163 | St. Davids GC |
| 1907 | Simon Carr | Huntingdon Valley CC | 159 | Merion Cricket Club |
| 1906 | *William P. Smith | Huntingdon Valley CC | 160 | Philadelphia CC |
| | Playoff: Smith & Simon Carr | | |
| 1905 | Harold B. McFarland | Huntingdon Valley CC | 157 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| 1904 | William P. Smith | Huntingdon Valley CC | 165 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 1903 | Harold B. McFarland | Huntingdon Valley CC | 155 | St. Davids GC |
| 1902 | Howard A. Perrin | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 168 | Merion Cricket Club |
| 1901 | George A. Crump | St. Davids GC | 175 | Philadelphia CC |
| 1900 | George D. Fowle | Philadelphia CC | 174 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (St. Martins) |
| |
| * — won in playoff |
| ^ — shortened to 36 holes |
| # — shortened to 18 holes |
