| 2023 | Braden Shattuck | Rolling Green GC | 68-66=134 | Lookaway GC |
| 2022 | ^John Brennan | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 72-67=139 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 2021 | Blake Hinckley | Wilmington CC | 66-69=135 | CC of York |
| 2020 | Michael Little | Lookaway GC | 68-70=138 | Doylestown CC |
| 2019 | ^Jeff Osberg | Pine Valley GC | 67-68=135 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 2018 | *Billy Stewart | The ACE Club | 69-66=135 | St. Davids GC |
| | Playoff (Four-hole aggregate): Stewart (14); ^Jeff Osberg, Huntingdon Valley CC (16) & Brett Melton, Radley Run CC (18) |
| 2017 | ^Matthew Mattare | Saucon Valley CC | 63-75=138 | Philadelphia CC |
| 2016 | *^Jeff Osberg | Huntingdon Valley CC | 71-71=142 | The Ridge at Back Brook |
| | Playoff (Four-hole aggregate): Osberg (17) & ^Chris Crawford, Spring Mill CC (18) |
| 2015 | ^Brandon Matthews | Blue Bell CC | 66-71=137 | Philadelphia Cricket Club (Wissahickon) |
| 2014 | ^Matt Teesdale | Commonwealth National GC | 68-68=136 | Applebrook GC |
| 2013 | *^Brandon Matthews | Glenmaura National GC | 70-70=140 | Waynesborough CC |
| | Playoff (Four-hole aggregate): Matthews (15) & Billy Stewart, Golf Galaxy (17) |
| 2012 | ^Andrew Mason | Huntingdon Valley CC | 70-74=144 | Pine Valley GC |
| 2011 | ^Andrew Mason | Huntingdon Valley CC | 65-70=135 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 2010 | *^Michael R. Brown, Jr. | Lookaway GC | 70-72=142 | Philmont CC (North) |
| | Playoff (Four-hole aggregate): Brown (16) & Greg Farrow, Deerwood CC (16); Brown won on first sudden-death hole with a par compared to a bogey |
| 2009 | Rich Steinmetz | Spring Ford CC | 68-64=132 | Bent Creek CC |
| 2008 | #Greg Pieczynski | Academy Golf School | 67 | Lookaway GC |
| 2007 | ^Mark Miller | Yardley CC | 71-69=140 | Merion GC (East) |
| 2006 | *Dave Quinn | Links GC | 70-69=139 | Llanerch CC |
| | Playoff (Four-hole aggregate): Quinn (15) & Mike Ladden, Philadelphia CC (17) |
| 2005 | Graham Dendler | Merion GC | 72-70=142 | Aronimink GC |
| 2004 | ^Chris Lange | Overbrook GC | 70-71=141 | Philadelphia CC |
| 2003 | Brian Kelly | Bucknell GC | 71-72=143 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 2002 | *John Appleget | Blue Heron Pines GC | 73-71=144 | Pine Valley GC |
| | Playoff: Appleget (72) & John DiMarco, Laurel Creek CC (76) |
| 2001 | Terry Hertzog | Gulph Mills GC | 70-67=137 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 2000 | *Brian Kelly | Bucknell GC | 70-71=141 | Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| | Playoff: Kelly (69), Pete Oakley, The Rookery (72) & Dave Roberts, Cedarbrook CC (73) |
| 1999 | Rick Osberg | Waynesborough CC | 68-70=138 | Waynesborough CC |
| 1998 | Jason Lamp | Blue Heron Pines GC | 70-66=136 | Aronimink GC |
| 1997 | #^Michael J. Brown, | Old York Road CC | 68 | Bent Creek CC |
| 1996 | Jim Booros | Allentown Municipal Golf Course | 73-69=142 | Stonewall |
| 1995 | Gene Feiger | Overbrook GC | 71-64=135 | Laurel Creek CC |
| 1994 | *Stu Ingraham | Overbrook GC | 136 | Kennett Square G&CC |
| | Playoff: Ingraham (67) & Harold Perry, Jr., Kennett Square G&CC (72) |
| 1993 | #Gene Feiger | Overbrook GC | 67 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 1992 | #*Frank Dobbs | Spring Ford CC | 68 | Philmont CC (North) |
| | Playoff: Dobbs (70), Harold Perry, Jr., Kennett Square G&CC (71), Chris Lange, Overbrook GC (71) & R. Jay Sigel, Aronimink GC (71) |
| 1991 | Frank Dobbs | Spring Ford CC | 72-67=139 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 1990 | Pete Oakley | Shawnee CC | 68-69=137 | Merion GC (East) |
| 1989 | Pete Oakley | Shawnee CC | 68-69=137 | Spring Ford CC |
| 1988 | James Masserio | Toftrees CC | 71-69=140 | Waynesborough CC |
| 1987 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 68-70=138 | Gulph Mills GC |
| 1986 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 67-69=136 | Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| 1985 | James Masserio | Toftrees CC | 70-71=141 | Sunnybrook GC |
| 1984 | Frank Dobbs | Oak Terrace CC | 68-73=141 | Indian Valley CC |
| 1983 | Ed Dougherty | Edgmont CC | 70-68=138 | Rolling Green GC |
| 1982 | Harold Perry | Tall Pines CC | 74-72=146 | Wilmington CC (South) |
| 1981 | Dick Hendrickson | Loch Nairn CC | 71-69=140 | Whitford CC |
| 1980 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 68-72=140 | Aronimink GC |
| 1979 | Jack Connelly | Huntingdon Valley CC | 74-71=145 | Philadelphia CC |
| 1978 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 74-71=145 | Merion GC (East) |
| 1977 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 69-71=140 | Saucon Valley CC (Old/Grace) |
| 1976 | Tim DeBaufre | Woodcrest CC | 65-76=141 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1975 | ^R. Jay Sigel | Aronimink GC | 66-71=137 | Bidermann GC |
| 1974 | *Joseph F. Data | Philadelphia CC | 70-72=142 | Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| | Playoff: Data (73) & Robert Bourne, Jr., Lancaster CC (74) |
| 1973 | Dick Hendrickson | PGA Tour | 69-70=139 | Atlantic City CC |
| 1972 | Dick Hendrickson | PGA Tour | 71-67=138 | Heidelberg CC |
| 1971 | *Ted McKenzie | Waynesborough CC | 70-70=140 | Aronimink GC |
| | Playoff: McKenzie (70) & Henry McQuiston, Bala GC (76) |
| 1970 | Dick Smith | Hi-Point Golf Farm | 68-73=141 | Philmont CC (North/South) |
| 1969 | ^William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 66-70=136 | Merion GC (East/West) |
| 1968 | ^William Hyndman, III | Huntingdon Valley CC | 67-75=142 | Waynesborough CC/Whitford CC |
| 1967 | John Kennedy | Edgmont CC | 69-71=140 | Atlantic City CC/Linwood CC |
| 1966 | Albert Besselink | Sunny Jim GC | 71-69=140 | Cedarbrook CC/Sandy Run CC |
| 1965 | *Jerry Pisano | Radnor Valley CC | 70-71=142 | Tavistock CC/Woodcrest CC |
| | Playoff: Pisano (75) & Ted McKenzie, Aronimink GC (76) |
| 1964 | Pat Schwab | Rock Manor CC | 68-72=140 | Philmont CC (North/South) |
| 1963 | *Albert Besselink, Philmont CC | | 73-71=144 | St. Davids GC/Aronimink GC |
| | *Playoff (Aronimink): Besselink (70); Sam Penecale, Whitemarsh Valley CC (74); Harvey Smith, Oak Terrace CC (75) |
| 1962 | Jerry Pisano | Radnor Valley CC | 71-69=140 | Philadelphia Cricket Club/North Hills CC |
| 1961 | Dick Sleichter | Gettysburg CC | 70-67=137 | Merion GC (East/West) |
| 1960 | Robert Riegel | Radnor Valley CC | 65-77=142 | Green Valley CC/Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| 1959 | George Fazio | Flourtown CC | 68-74=142 | Aronimink GC/Overbrook GC |
| 1958 | &George Fazio | Pine Valley GC | 78-69=147 | Merion GC (East) |
| | &Jack Penrose, Atlantic City CC unavailable for playoff |
| 1957 | Jerry Pisano | Overbrook GC | 68-71=139 | The Springhaven Club |
| 1956 | George Fazio | Fairmount Park | 73-64=137 | Overbrook GC |
| 1955 | *Henry Williams, Jr. | Berkleigh CC | 70-69=139 | Atlantic City CC |
| | Playoff: Williams (69) & George Fazio, Fairmount Park (71) |
| 1954 | Ralph Hutchison | Saucon Valley CC | 72-70=142 | Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| 1953 | George Griffin, Jr. | Green Valley GC | 75-71=146 | Green Valley GC |
| 1952 | George Fazio | Pine Valley GC | 143 | North Hills CC |
| 1951 | Henry Williams, Jr. | Berkleigh CC | 71-70=141 | Llanerch CC |
| 1950 | Joseph Lewis | Manufacturers’ G&CC | 73-68=141 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 1949 | George Fazio | Unaffiliated | 71-67=138 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1948 | ^James B. McHale, Jr. | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 70-70=140 | Atlantic City CC |
| 1947 | Gene Kunes | Englewood GC | 69-67=136 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 1946 | Matt Kowal | Philmont CC | 141 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1945 | No Contest |
| 1944 | Joe Zarhardt | Jeffersonville GC | 138 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| 1943 | No Contest |
| 1942 | Joseph Lewis | Tredyffrin CC | 69-67=136 | Llanerch CC |
| 1941 | Terl Johnson | Pymouth CC | 146 | Pine Valley GC |
| 1940 | Ed B. Dudley | Philadelphia CC | 142 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| Format changed to Medal Play (36 holes) |
|
| 1939 | Sam D. Byrd | Philadelphia CC | 284 | Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| 1938 | Ted Turner | Pine Valley GC | 70-73-70-73=286 | Torresdale-Frankford CC |
| 1937 | *Leonard Dodson | Springfield, Mo. | 75-70-69-70=284 | Concord CC |
| | Playoff: Dodson (74) & Bruce Coltart, Woodcrest CC (75) |
| 1936 | *Ed B. Dudley | Philadelphia CC | 286 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| | Playoff: Dudley (69) & Charles Lacey, Lakeville CC (73) |
| 1935 | Ted Turner | Pine Valley GC | 292 | Aronimink GC |
| 1934 | Herman Barron | Kings Ridge GC | 284 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1933 | Ed B. Dudley | Concord CC | 72-72-75-69=288 | Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| 1932 | George E. Griffin, Sr. | Green Valley CC | 291 | Paxon Hollow GC |
| 1931 | %Clarence W. Hackney | CC of Atlantic City | 147 | Manufacturers’ G&CC |
| | %Shortened to 54 holes due to inclement weather |
| 1930 | Clarence W. Hackney | CC of Atlantic City | 295 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 1929 | Ed B. Dudley | Concord CC | 295 | Merion CC (East) |
| 1928 | Tommy D. Armour | Congressional CC | 292 | North Hills CC |
| 1927 | John Farrell | Quaker Ridge GC | 296 | Rolling Green GC |
| 1926 | Emmett French | Southern Pines, N.C. | 292 | Philmont CC (North) |
| 1925 | John Farrell | Quaker Ridge GC | 292 | Cedarbrook CC |
| 1924 | @Joe Kirkwood, Sr. | Rockwood Hall CC | 142 | Atlantic City CC |
| | @Shortened to 36 holes due to inclement weather |
| 1923 | Clarence W. Hackney | CC of Atlantic City | 298 | Pine Valley GC |
| 1922 | Charles H. Hoffner | Philmont CC | 301 | Merion CC (East) |
| 1921 | Willie MacFarlane | Oak Ridge GC | 294 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1920 | Frank T. MacNamara | Cherry Valley Club | 294 | Atlantic City CC |
| 1919 | Emmett French | CC of York | 306 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1918 | Pat Doyle/Arthur Reid | Deal G&CC/Stoneybrook GC | 150 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| | Declared co-champions after initial two rounds rained out |
| 1917 | James Barnes | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 306 | Merion CC |
| 1916 | %James Fraser | Seaview GC | 226 | Philmont CC (South) |
| | %Shortened to 54 holes due to inclement weather |
| 1915 | Tom McNamara | Boston, Mass. | 296 | Philadelphia CC |
| 1914 | Tom McNamara | Boston, Mass. | 302 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1913 | Johnny J. McDermott | Atlantic City CC | 305 | Merion CC |
| Format changed to Medal Play (72 holes) |
|
| 1912 | *Gilbert Nichols | Wilmington CC | 149 | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| | Playoff: Nichols (71) & Johnny J. McDermott, Atlantic City CC |
| 1911 | Johnny J. McDermott | Atlantic City CC | 150 | Whitemarsh Valley CC |
| 1910 | Johnny J. McDermott | Merchantville Field Club | 146 | Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| 1909 | Gilbert Nichols | Wilmington CC | 146 | Philadelphia CC |
| Format changed to Medal Play (36 holes) |
|
| 1908 | Jack Campbell, Overbrook GC, d. James Campbell, Whitemarsh Valley CC | 1-up | The Springhaven Club |
| 1907 | James Campbell, Mt. Airy CC, d. William Robinson, Atlantic City CC | 2-up | Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| 1906 | Donald Ball, Philadelphia Cricket Club, d. Jack Campbell, Overbrook GC | 2-up | Mt. Airy CC |
| 1905 | James Campbell, Mt. Airy CC, d. Donald Ball, Philadelphia Cricket Club | 2-up | Huntingdon Valley CC |
| 1904 | Jack Campbell, Huntingdon Valley CC, d. Tom Clark, Wilmington CC | 6&5 | Bala CC |
| Format changed to Match Play |
|
| 1903 | Jack Campbell | Huntingdon Valley CC | 321 | Philadelphia Cricket Club |
| Format is Medal Play (72 holes) |
|
| #Event shortened to 18 holes |
| ^Amateur |
| *Won in playoff |
