| 2023 | Jeff Homer | Wilmington CC | 287 |
| 2022 | *Josh Ryan | The 1912 Club | 277 |
| Playoff (Sandy Run): Ryan (67) & Matthew Homer, Wilmington CC (69) |
| 2021 | Jeff Homer | Wilmington CC | 285 |
| 2020 | #Jake Maddaloni | Aronimink GC | 212 |
| 2019 | #Patrick Sheehan | Talamore CC | 208 |
| 2018 | Anthony Barr | Blue Bell CC | 287 |
| 2017 | Ron Robinson | Commonwealth National GC | 299 |
| 2016 | Ron Robinson | Talamore CC | 288 |
| 2015 | *J.T. Barker | Saucon Valley CC | 282 |
| Playoff (Sandy Run): Barker (71, 3) & Max Siegfried, Aronimink GC (71, 4) |
| 2014 | Blaine Lafferty | Burlington CC | 288 |
| 2013 | *Cole Berman | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 281 |
| Playoff (Talamore): Berman (73) & Jalen Griffin, Talamore CC (74) |
| 2012 | Cole Berman | Philadelphia Cricket Club | 279 |
| 2011 | Reilly Erhardt | Trenton CC | 295 |
| 2010 | Ted Brennan | Philadelphia CC | 292 |
| 2009 | Edward McCrossen, Jr. | Whitemarsh Valley CC | 285 |
| 2008 | Michael Kania | Overbrook GC | 292 |
| 2007 | Russell Hartung | Doylestown CC | 294 |
| *Jock MacKenzie Memorial incorporated into award* |
| 2006 | Bobby Arthur | Tavistock CC | 223 |
| 2005 | Eric Schmehl | Moorestown Field Club | 217 |
| 2004 | Brian Creghan | Plymouth CC | 222 |
| 2003 | Craig Tallent | Merion GC | 216 |
| 2002 | *James Robertson, Jr. | Llanerch CC | 221 |
| Playoff (Huntingdon Valley): Robertson (74) & Tyler Rae, Deerfield G&TC (82) |
| 2001 | Billy Stewart | Llanerch CC | 215 |
| 2000 | Billy Stewart | Llanerch CC | 225 |
| |
| # — shortened to 54 holes |
| * — won in playoff |
